Bake My Day

Multiple customers, including one who needed a cake on Christmas Eve with less than 24 hours' notice, report that Bake My Day successfully accommodated urgent requests and delivered high-quality, customized cakes. However, one review mentions a delay in pickup time without prior notice, suggesting occasional scheduling misunderstandings.

Source: 2 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium-high (explicit mention of last-minute successful order)

Five of eight reviewers describe the cakes as delicious, beautiful, and moist, with specific praise for flavor combinations like Pina Colada, Peanut Butter Chocolate, and Mad Science inspiration. One reviewer noted that the frosting was buttercream instead of the requested whipped cream, which some guests found too sugary for diabetics.

Source: 5 of 8 reviews • Confidence: high (recurring theme of delicious and beautiful cakes)

• Frosting preference: buttercream (some guests preferred whipped cream)

Several reviewers commend Christine for her responsiveness, kindness, and willingness to go above and beyond, especially in emergency situations. However, one negative review describes unprofessional behavior, including a defensive tone, additional undisclosed charges, and the sharing of private information, leading to a breakdown in trust.

Source: 2 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium (conflicting themes of professionalism)

One review mentions an unexpected $15 additional charge after a non-refundable deposit was sent, while another reports a deposit of $45 for a $150 cake with dissatisfaction over the cake's tier and decoration. These indicate occasional misunderstandings about pricing and deposit policies.

Source: 2 of 8 reviews • Confidence: low (limited evidence of pricing disputes)