Mrs Redd's Pie Co

Multiple customers recall the pies tasting the same as in their childhood, praising the nostalgic flavor. However, some recent reviews note that the apple pies have become smaller and the taste has shifted toward butter and salt, deviating from the classic apple flavor.

Source: 7 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium-high (recurring theme)

Several reviewers mention that while the fillings are delicious and better than mass-produced brands like Hostess, the crust can be soggy or lack crunch, and the glaze application is sometimes inconsistent.

Source: 4 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium (limited evidence)

One review indicates that the pies are not always in stock at Stater Bros and suggests they should be more widely available at other retailers.

Source: 1 of 8 reviews • Confidence: low (single mention)

Lemon and apple pies are highlighted as favorites, with customers describing them as delicious and nostalgic, even traveling long distances to purchase them.

Source: 4 of 8 reviews • Confidence: high (explicit mention)

• Popular flavors: Lemon, Apple