My NY Sports Pizza

Multiple customers highlight that My NY Sports Pizza serves authentic New York-style pizza, noting its large size, crispy crust, and generous toppings. Several reviewers specifically mention the 28-inch pepperoni pizza and signature cheese balls as standout items.

Source: 5 of 8 reviews • Confidence: high (explicit mention)

• Popular toppings: pepperoni, sausage, Hawaiian
• Signature item: cheese balls

Several reviewers describe the prices as reasonable, especially considering the large portion sizes. One review notes that a giant 28-inch pizza costs around $60‑$70, while a lunch special offers a 14‑inch slice with a drink or draft beer for $8.99.

Source: 4 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium-high (recurring theme)

• Lunch special: $8.99 for 14-inch slice + drink or beer

Guests often mention a lively sports bar atmosphere with many TVs showing various sports, a modern industrial decor, and a fun vibe with sports memorabilia. One review notes the place can get crowded, especially during peak times.

Source: 7 of 8 reviews • Confidence: high (recurring theme)

• Atmosphere: lively sports bar with many TVs
• Decor: modern industrial with sports memorabilia

Multiple customers praise the friendly and attentive staff, noting quick service and helpful recommendations. One review mentions the cashier was very friendly and checked on patrons often.

Source: 6 of 8 reviews • Confidence: high (explicit mention)

• Service: friendly and attentive

One review expressed disappointment with a missing sauce on the pepperoni pizza, suggesting patrons should ask for sauce. This is the only negative feedback among the reviews.

Source: 1 of 8 reviews • Confidence: low (limited evidence)

• Criticisms: potential sauce omission on pizza