Oddball Ice Cream

Multiple customers highlight a variety of creative flavors such as Bigfoot sundae, pistachio/vanilla/chocolate malt, strawberry cheesecake, butter pecan, cookies and cream, mint chocolate, cheesecake sundae, birthday cake dipped cone, and salted caramel. Guests often mention the owner's willingness to customize orders, including sugar-free options.

Source: 7 of 8 reviews • Confidence: high (explicit mention)

• Offers custom sugar-free sundaes
• Known for unique flavor combinations

Several reviewers describe the staff, possibly the owner, as kind, funny, attentive, and accommodating. They note the owner chats with customers and offers additional amenities like allowing guests to eat ice cream next door in an art center.

Source: 8 of 8 reviews • Confidence: high (recurring theme)

• Owner engages in friendly conversation
• Offers flexible dining options

Multiple customers emphasize that the price is incredible, with all four family members enjoying their treats for under $30. Guests describe the shop as affordable and good value for the quality of ice cream and service.

Source: 5 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium-high (explicit mention)

• All four family members under $30
• Affordable yet high-quality

Guests often mention that Oddball Ice Cream is a great quick stop for something sweet, with a clean interior and a variety of choices despite its small size. The absence of indoor seating is noted but not a deterrent.

Source: 6 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium (recurring theme)

• Quick stop for sweet treats
• Clean interior, small but sufficient

One review specifically mentions that the owners participate in local community events, such as Christmas toy drives where donors received a free scoop, indicating community support.

Source: 1 of 8 reviews • Confidence: low (single mention)

• Participates in local Christmas toy drives