Pickle's Pie Shop

Several reviewers found the savory pies, especially the Season Beef Pot Pie and Famous Chicken Pot Pie, disappointing. The crust was criticized for being oily and not flaky, and the fillings were described as fatty or overly salty. The pies were noted to be served frozen and required a 90-minute bake time.

Source: 2 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium (explicit mention)

Sweet pies received varied feedback. Some guests appreciated the True Love pie for its balanced sweet and tart flavors, while others found the Ultimate Cherry and Black Berry Apple pies overly sweet with subpar crusts. Overall, the sweet pies were seen as lacking in filling and crust quality.

Source: 3 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium (mixed themes)

Service was generally described as friendly, but the atmosphere was noted as unwelcoming initially. The ordering process was slow despite a straightforward menu. Multiple reviews suggested improvements in store layout and service could enhance the customer experience.

Source: 3 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium (recurring theme)

Pricing was a mixed topic. Some reviewers found the pies pricey but considered them fairly priced for their freshness and unique flavors. Others expected better quality given the high prices, particularly for savory pies that were described as fatty or salty.

Source: 4 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium-high (recurring theme)

Multiple reviews highlighted long wait times, often due to high demand and limited staff. Customers reported waiting 30 minutes to over an hour, especially during peak times like opening or holidays. The shop is known for selling out quickly, necessitating early arrival or pre-ordering.

Source: 5 of 8 reviews • Confidence: high (explicit mention)

• Wait times can exceed 45 minutes due to high demand.

The lemon pie was repeatedly praised as a family favorite, and the apple white peach pie was described as out of this world with a flaky crust and fresh fruit chunks. Unique flavor profiles, such as those in the Blackberry Honey Peach and strawberry-rhubarb pies, were highlighted as distinct and highly regarded.

Source: 3 of 8 reviews • Confidence: high (explicit mention)

• Lemon pie is a standout favorite.

Customers advised double-checking receipts for order accuracy, arriving early or ordering ahead to secure desired pies, and keeping frozen pies frozen until baking. The shop's limited seating and COVID-related dining room closure were also noted.

Source: 3 of 8 reviews • Confidence: medium (practical advice)

• Arrive early or order ahead to avoid disappointment.